Category: Benefits

  • There’s nothing left to cut. There is something left to explain.

    Insights · Benefits & renewal

    Every September the renewal comes in and someone looks at what’s left to take out of the plan. Usually there’s nothing left. The next number is sitting in whether people actually use the coverage they have.

    Daneen Gurney · September 2026

    I’ve sat in enough renewal meetings to know the pattern. The broker walks in with an increase. The owner looks at HR. HR looks at last year’s list of “optimizations” — tighter network, higher deductible, a wellness vendor nobody used — and there’s nothing left on that list that moves the number. Plan design is already squeezed. Cost-sharing is already shifted about as far as it’ll go. The bill still goes up.

    I mean, this is the conversation that’s been the same for as long as I’ve been in this business. We treat the renewal like a procurement event. Shop the plan. Change the metal level. Add a program with a clever name. Then we act surprised when the people on the plan didn’t get any healthier, didn’t get to the doctor sooner, and didn’t stay on the payroll long enough for any of that math to matter.

    This is not the workers’ compensation conversation. That one has its own numbers and its own season. This one is about the health and longevity of the workforce heading into the next renewal — whether anyone can find a primary care physician, whether the benefit anyone fought for last year is being used by the right people, whether a forty-year-old with rising blood pressure hears about it in time to change the claim that shows up eighteen months from now.

    What the industry is putting the AI on

    My friend Randy Wood wrote about this in NAPEO’s PEO Insider last month. He was not writing a sales piece. He was writing about benefits communication — the unglamorous work of getting a human being to understand what they already have.

    43%Of organizations now using AI in HR tasks, per SHRM
    68%Of employers say communication is their top AI-in-benefits priority, per Willis Towers Watson
    59% / 57%Analytics and personalized support, same WTW 2026 survey

    The argument underneath those numbers is not mysterious. The data already lives in the system. The hard part is explaining coverage to someone who does not want to read a PDF. That is why communication is where employers are putting AI first. Lowest drama. Closest to the employee. Fastest chance of someone actually using the plan instead of waiting until the ER is the front door.

    Why that belongs in the renewal room

    Here’s the part I think gets missed. If the old levers are maxed out, the only lever left is whether the plan does what it was bought to do. A renewal packet that only shows trend, contribution, and network disruption is a procurement document. It does not tell an owner whether last year’s coverage changed anyone’s year.

    Yeah, there’s that — the packet goes out, three people skim the rate page, and next September you are back in the same chairs asking why the number moved again.

    A plain-language read of this employer, this census, this year — who is not using preventive care, which benefits were added and sat untouched, where the spend is concentrating — is a different conversation. Not because it is fashionable. Because it is the only conversation that still has anywhere to go after you have already tightened the network.

    AI can draft that read in the time it used to take to find last year’s PowerPoint. It cannot decide what the workforce needs. It cannot make a person go to the doctor. It cannot promise the next renewal will come down. What it can do is stop us from walking into September with a generic comparison and calling that a strategy for the people on the plan.

    If the next number is going to be any different, it will be because this year’s employees were healthier, stayed longer, and used the plan on purpose. That work starts in the explanation, not in another deductible.

    Source: Randy Wood, “AI for PEOs: Save Time and Drive Growth by Rethinking Benefits Communication,” NAPEO PEO Insider, August 2026. Figures in the article are attributed to SHRM and Willis Towers Watson’s 2026 AI in Health and Benefits Survey.